◆ Stacks
HORMUZ MINES
Steve Hanke (@steve_hanke) · 2026-08-04 · original: EN

Reopening Hormuz is not a matter of signing a piece of paper

Open in the Stacks app → Read the original ↗

Last year, 60 tankers crossed the Strait of Hormuz on August 3.

This year, 5 tankers crossed on August 3.

THANKS TO PRES. TRUMP, THE STRAIT IS, FOR ALL PRACTICAL PURPOSES, CLOSED.

Steve Hanke · 2026.08.04

US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on August 4 that a deal to reopen the Strait of Hormuz could arrive within the week. Brent crude fell that day to its lowest level in three weeks, and more than 1,000 ships are backed up waiting to cross the strait.

Bessent says there may be a deal Tuesday or Wednesday to open the Strait of Hormuz with freedom of movement (CNBC, 2026-08-04)
출처: cnbc.com

Traffic is already down to single digits

Economist Steve Hanke wrote that only 5 tankers crossed on August 3, versus 60 on the same day a year earlier. We could not verify those two figures against a primary source. The direction and scale, though, hold up elsewhere. Lloyd's List Intelligence counted 39 tanker transits for the week of July 13 to 19. USNI News reported that daily transits have stayed in single digits every day since July 19.

June 29-Jul 5109 transits
Jul 6-1285 transits
Jul 13-1939 transits

Traffic cut by a third in two weeks. This is the stretch where the brief revival from June's memorandum dried up again.

Lloyd's List Intelligence weekly tally (2026-07-21 brief, cited in USNI News 2026-07-31)

This is the second attempt

This lane has already opened once and shut again. The benchmark for reading this deal is not its wording but what broke the last one.

Al Jazeera (2026-07-09, 2026-08-02), EIA (2026-06-09)

Nobody has been named to clear the mines

Even with a deal, ships cannot cross right away. Mines laid in the strait are still there. Bloomberg reported on August 4 that Iran is informally weighing letting European countries clear the mines. The same day, Iran's deputy foreign minister Kazem Gharibabadi stated publicly that only Iran will do the clearing.

Iran weighs allowing Europe to clear Hormuz mines (Bloomberg, 2026-08-04)
출처: finance.yahoo.com

Clearing mines does not end with a signature. Minesweepers have to comb a narrow channel back and forth, repeatedly, while sitting within range of Iran's coastal firepower the entire time. Until someone is named to send those ships, the freedom of movement written into the deal stays on paper. What Hanke blamed was Trump's decision. What is actually blocking traffic is sitting underwater.

What to watch on August 19

Whether this deal actually moved ships will be confirmed by transit counts, not by whether it was signed. If daily transits climb into double digits, some form of mine clearance has begun; if they stay in single digits, the deal amounted to an announcement. While the strait has been effectively shut, Saudi Arabia's East-West pipeline and the UAE's Fujairah route have absorbed part of the volume. Combined, the two fall well short of Hormuz's normal throughput. So whether this strait opens or stays shut moves not just the oil price but Asian refiners' crude procurement costs, freight rates, and war risk insurance all at once.

In three lines

Scheduled for gradingAwaiting grading

Metric
Daily tanker transits through the Strait of Hormuz
Now
Single digits every day since July 19 (39 transits in the week of July 13-19)
Grading date
August 19, 2026 (two weeks after Bessent's remark)
Hit
Daily transits recover to double digits, meaning the reopening deal is actually working
Miss
Daily transits stay in single digits, meaning the deal never translated into traffic

Sources

  1. Original Steve Hanke (@steve_hanke) · comparing Hormuz transits on August 3 last year and this year (60 vs. 5) · 2026-08-04
  2. CNBC CNBC · Treasury Secretary Bessent says a Hormuz reopening deal could come Tuesday or Wednesday · 2026-08-04
  3. Bloomberg (via Yahoo Finance) Reports Iran is weighing letting European states clear Hormuz mines, while Iran's deputy foreign minister says only Iran will do the clearing · 2026-08-04
  4. Al Jazeera Reports no breakthrough on reopening Hormuz even after Trump halted the strike campaign · 2026-08-02
  5. Lloyd's List Intelligence / USNI News Lloyd's List Intelligence weekly transit tally (three-week trend, June 29 to July 19), as cited in USNI News's article dated 2026-07-31

Retrieved 2026-08-05 · transit counts per Lloyd's List Intelligence weekly tally, oil price as of the August 4 close